I have blogged before about the shrinking diplomatic options open to the international community when dealing with Iran. I concluded then, that the only path left open was the UN UPR process. It appears Iran has put the final nail in their diplomatic coffin by refusing to take up some of the most basic recommendations that the UPR made.
Iran refused to accept the recommendation that it end the practice of executing juveniles, upholding fair trial guarantees and investigating torture allegations. Perhaps the biggest blow was their refusal to allow the Council’s Special Rapporteur on torture to visit the country. If they will not even play lip service to such basic demands then what hope is there of any effective change within the country?
There is however, one last hope – Iran’s diplomatic schizophrenia seems to have come out once again during this process. They accepted some recommendations while rejecting other similar recommendations. There is potential for random positive acts to occur, but this is far from sustainable. We cannot allow their regime to dictate when it will coöperate; equally we cannot risk casting them off into the diplomatic wilderness where human rights abuses can occur unchecked.
If we want real progress for human rights in Iran, we need the authorities there to start living up to their responsibilities; such as their commitments under the Convention on the Rights of the Child not to execute juveniles. It is up to the International community to keep banging the same drum asking the Iranian authorities to act. It may feel like it does nothing, but what other options are available?
2 responses to “Iran makes a mockery of the UPR”
Pingback: Israel boycotts UN human rights session despite warnings from friends and foe | Hynd's Blog
It is not new that many times the parallel view that may indicate is that the power-hungry super-power US is wildly playing the weapon of ‘international diplomacy’ card to subdue the emerging Iran. The US may view Iran as a ‘thorn’ in its path of progress and expansion. Iran’s right to exist and fight is to be respected equally.