This is not a radical cry for the removal of political parties from our decision making mechanism. Far from it. This is merely a cry to those tiny number of people on the insides of national and local parties. Please, for the love of Hynd’s Blog, take off those ridiculous rosettes.
They are a symbol of one of the strongest held perceptions in politics and that is that politicians cannot be trusted. If you want to be listened to – start by taking off your rosettes.
For a long-time now I have encouraged any candidate of any political party to take off their rosette. This normally occurs when they are about to go infringing on people’s personal space and time by ‘door knocking’.
I do this not because their particular flavour of political party might be unpopular than but because politics per se is.
Or, to be more accurate, politicians are.
By wearing a rosette politicians shoot themselves in the foot on the first step they hope to take on their journey of democratic representation.
At the crux of my argument is the assertion that if you want a constituent to talk to you, let alone trust or vote for you, then you need to give yourself a fighting chance in the first few seconds on the doorstep. This is unlikely to happen if you were a badge that basically says, ‘Watch out, I’m a politician.’
As much as you might honestly believe that you are different to all the others, or your party is not like those overs, most people don’t share these subtleties. They see you – a politician – as untrustworthy.
New polling from IPSOS-Mori out today highlights how deeply rooted this mistrust of politicians is. Just 16% of respondents said they would trust a politician to tell the truth. This is an opinion as old as IPSOS-Mori’s polling.
In other words, even if you got a constituent to listen to you, about 84% of constituents wouldn’t trust what you have to say. This is more than bankers…a profession not known at the moment for their commitment to honesty.
This might seem like a trivial point but it is one of the pebbles on the starting line of democracy that is tripping up genuine interaction and engagement.
It’s axiomatic that the removal of the rosette is only the first step to rebuilding trust. The long road ahead in our efforts to resuscitate democracy involves strange concepts like keeping promises and working hard to represent constituents needs.
But that is for tomorrow. Today, still with 4 months left until the election, I beg and implore candidates and sitting MPs, MEPs and Cllrs alike – get rid of those ridiculous rosette.
3 responses to “Take rosettes out of politics to help resuscitate democracy”
Which is why I respect the Green Party as the only real organisation representative of my views about politics.
Unfortunately they are often unrepresentative of my views about other stuff…
I agree, ditch the rosettes: but it is what they represent which I mistrust the most.
Almost anyone could knock at my door and we could have a full and frank exchange of views on a wide range of subjects. But I know that a vote for that individual, really, would be a vote for their party, which means a vote for the policies pre-ordained by the whips. Candidates aren’t much more than door-to-door salesmen for the product, the party, none of whom I trust in any way, shape or form.
To put it another way, I wouldn’t want to vote for a Labour candidate, no matter how reasonable his views on Cheltenham’s road network might be, because a vote for him would be a vote for Ed Milliband.
Worth noting that Greens don’t use a whips system and some (although too few) MPs do spend their lives on the backbenches because they ignore the whips